Skip to main content
LocalCardFinder.comYour local game store, found.Add your store

Magic Stores in the New York Area

The New York area has 97 local game stores across 53 cities that carry Magic. Of these, 87 sell single cards and 92 stock sealed product. Browse the map, hours, and what each shop stocks below.

Loading map…
Refine Magic stores in New York with filters

Magic by city in New York: Brooklyn (16), New York (16), Flushing (5), Staten Island (5), Bayonne (3), Bronx (3), Hoboken (2), Ridgewood (2), Astoria (1), Baldwin (1), Bloomfield (1), Cedar Grove (1), Clifton (1), Corona (1), East Newark (1), Edison (1), Elmont (1), Englewood (1), Fords (1), Forest Hills (1), Harrison (1), Hillsdale (1), Inwood (1), Irvington (1), Jersey City (1), Kenilworth (1), Larchmont (1), Leonia (1), Levittown (1), Livingston (1), Long Island City (1), Lynbrook (1), Lyndhurst (1), Maplewood (1), Matawan (1), Middle Village (1), Montclair (1), newark (1), Oceanside (1), Paramus (1), Pompton Plains (1), River Edge (1), Scotch Plains (1), South Amboy (1), South Plainfield (1), Springfield (1), Valley Stream (1), West New York (1), Westbury (1), Whitestone (1), Woodbridge Township (1), Woodside (1), Yonkers (1)

Buying Magic around New York

87 of the 97 Magic stores in the New York area sell single cards, your best bet for chasing specific staples or finishing a set. 92 shops stock sealed product such as booster boxes, bundles, and packs. 82 carry both, so you can grab packs and chase singles in one trip.

Across these shops, customers leave an average of 4.6★ over 31,369 Google reviews. Use the map above to find the closest one.

Frequently asked questions

How many Magic stores are in the New York area?
97 local game stores across 53 cities in the New York metro carry Magic, according to localcardfinder.com.
Where can I buy Magic singles near New York?
87 of the Magic stores in the New York area sell single cards. Open the map above or browse the listings to find the closest shop.
Which New York stores sell sealed Magic product?
92 stores in the New York area that carry Magic also stock sealed product such as booster boxes and packs. Check each listing for current availability.

Other games in New York: Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Sports, One Piece, Lorcana, Board & Other, Riftbound, Flesh & Blood, Star Wars

← All game stores in New York · Magic stores nationwide