MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!Board & Other
Singles Sealed
1.1 miChart a course
Loading map…
Max Rarity
WPNOTS
SinglesSealed
What you'll find in the bins
Magic
The original TCG, still chasing staples.
Pokémon
The set everyone's opening right now.
Yu-Gi-Oh!
A meta that rewrites itself every season.
One Piece
Build a crew, pick your leader.
Lorcana
Disney characters, reimagined in ink.
Star Wars
Pick your side of the Force.
Riftbound
League of Legends, now on the table.
About
Valley Stream's hub for gamers and collectors, Max Rarity runs a Crystal Commerce storefront stacked with singles and sealed across Magic, Pokemon, Yu-Gi-Oh, One Piece, Lorcana, Star Wars Unlimited, Riftbound and more. Got cards to move? Their buylist takes singles and sealed. Open late most nights for drafts and play.
Good to know
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entranceAccessible parkingAccessible restroomAccessible seating
Parking
Free parking lotFree street parkingPaid street parking
Payment
Credit cardsDebit cardsContactless / tap
From 127 customer reviews
What the players say
Great place! Very chill atmosphere and the employees are very helpful and knowledgeable about all products I inquired about (Pokémon & MTG) Because Im disabled I couldn't make it to the most recent prerelease event, but I managed to go there the following week and buy a bunch of…
MD
Mike Dee
2 months ago
I've been hosting D&D one shots at Max Rarity (almost) every Sunday since 2025. This is an amazing place, very comfortable, inviting, well lit, spacious, and just generally a nice place. They have snacks and drinks, Magic the Gathering, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh, Riftbound, One Piece,…
AV
Angelo Vartholomeou
8 months ago
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Randy at Max Rarity in Valley Stream was absolutely amazing! He has a fantastic personality, super accommodating, patient, and easy to talk to. The shop itself was clean, well-organized, and had an incredible selection of inventory. Randy took the time to help me pick…
KC
Khoang C
5 months ago
cool shop but they don't honor the official bandai app. you have to pre register on their website which they don't mention on the bandai app. reserving a lot on the official app means nothing which is stupid cause then whats the point. came all the way from the city and got…
DH
Donna Hax
a month ago
Had a very disappointing experience here. I brought in a high-value piece for sale, and while I understand shops need to make a margin, the owner’s attitude was completely unprofessional. When I tried to negotiate a very small $50 difference, he became aggressive and refused to…