Skip to main content
LocalCardFinder.comYour local game store, found.Add your store

Magic Stores in New York

Across New York, 113 local game stores carry Magic, spread over 64 cities. 97 sell singles and 105 keep sealed product in stock. Jump to a city below, or scan every listing for hours and what each shop stocks.

Magic by city in New York: Brooklyn (16), New York (16), Flushing (5), Rochester (5), Staten Island (5), Bronx (3), Buffalo (2), North Tonawanda (2), Ridgewood (2), Syracuse (2), Webster (2), Amherst (1), Astoria (1), Baldwin (1), Batavia (1), Binghamton (1), Cheektowaga (1), Chester (1), Corona (1), Cortlandt Manor (1), Deer Park (1), Elbridge (1), Elmont (1), Forest Hills (1), Fulton (1), Geneva (1), Glenmont (1), Hamburg (1), Herkimer (1), Holland Patent (1), Horseheads (1), Irvington (1), Ithaca (1), Jamestown (1), Lake Ronkonkoma (1), Larchmont (1), Levittown (1), Lockport (1), Long Island City (1), Lynbrook (1), Manlius (1), Middle Village (1), New City (1), New Paltz (1), Newburgh (1), Norwich (1), Oneida (1), Plattsburgh (1), Potsdam (1), Poughkeepsie (1), Queensbury (1), Rensselaer (1), Valley Stream (1), Walton (1), Waterloo (1), Watertown (1), Westbury (1), White Plains (1), Whitehall (1), Whitesboro (1), Whitestone (1), Williamsville (1), Woodside (1), Yonkers (1)

Showing the top 48 of 113 stores. The city links above list every shop in each spot.

Finding Magic across New York

97 of the 113 Magic stores in New York deal in single cards. Hunting a specific staple? Start with those, and call ahead, since binder stock varies shop to shop. 105 keep sealed product on the shelf: booster boxes, bundles, packs. 89 handle both singles and sealed, which saves a second stop.

Shoppers rate these stores 4.6★ on average across 35,510 Google reviews. Each listing shows current hours and what the shop carries.

Frequently asked questions

Which cities in New York have Magic stores?
64 New York cities have at least one store carrying Magic, with the most listings in Brooklyn, New York, and Flushing. The city links above go straight to each local list.
Where can I buy Magic singles in New York?
97 of the 113 New York stores carrying Magic deal in single cards. Each listing on this page shows whether a shop sells singles, sealed product, or both.
Do New York game stores stock sealed Magic product?
105 stores in New York stock sealed product such as booster boxes and packs. Sealed availability turns over with each set release, so check a shop's listing for hours before making the drive.
How are Magic stores in New York rated?
Customers average 4.6 stars over 35,510 Google reviews across the Magic stores listed here.

Other games in New York: Board & Other, Flesh & Blood, Lorcana, One Piece, Pokémon, Riftbound, Sports, Star Wars, Yu-Gi-Oh!

← All game stores in New York · Magic stores nationwide