MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaStar WarsRiftboundFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
Loading map…
The Toys Of Our Lives
SinglesSealed
Graded cardsVintage
What you'll find in the bins
About
A Verona nostalgia shop blending vintage toys, comics, and trading cards — with a standout Pokémon case of graded cards and unopened boxes. A collector's paradise just outside Madison.
Good to know
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entranceAccessible parking
Payment
Credit cardsDebit cards
From 51 customer reviews
What the players say
I’ve been waiting for a worthy vintage toy store in the Midwest for years. The Toys of Our Lives is amazing. Part Toy Store/Part Toy Museum. While there have been some worthy stores that have come and (sadly) gone, The Toys of Our Lives is an amazing find. I lived in Los Angeles…
TY
Tou Yang
7 months ago
Very nice owner and informative of collectibles in the store. It had a wide variety of toy collectibles and cards. This is a great spot for kids and anyone looking for the special items. I found some vintage pokemon cards which I have been searching for.
AS
Aries Sindain
5 months ago
One of the most over priced resell stores I've ever been too. Went in thinking it would be fun with some spending money, and left with one $45 item witch I then found out later that night that I had paid almost double what the item was worth. Great selection, but not a single…
KN
Kyle Norton
4 months ago
I recommend visiting just to see the collection. The organization of the store is the best and coolest that I have ever seen. It's a must visit for any collector, or just for a fun nostalgia hit!
AR
Andres Rodriguez
3 months ago
We were visiting from Milwaukee and ran into this spot and holy cow is it awesome!! Great selection of old and new and the owner was incredibly kind and knowledgeable!!