Skip to main content
LocalCardFinder.comYour local game store, found.Add your store
Back to the huntChart a course
Loading map…

The Game Cave

Batavia, NY4.4(39 reviews)Tapped in · open now
SinglesSealed

What you'll find in the bins

About

Batavia's spot for paper Magic, billed as the only place in town with MTG tournaments and singles. Expect a deep Standard, Modern and Legacy singles selection plus restockable sealed at or below MSRP. Yu-Gi-Oh and D&D round out the focus, with a welcoming play space for board games and RPGs too.

Good to know

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entranceAccessible parking
Payment
Credit cardsDebit cardsContactless / tap

What the players say

RR
ronlad raygunnn
3 weeks ago

Great place to start learning how to play mtg, and fun events. everyone I have meet so far has been patient with me still learning the game. Frank has been a huge help with getting me the cards I needed or pointing me in the right direction for my decks.

RW
Richie Williams
a month ago

My son and I stopped by this shop while we were in town for a few days. The guy behind the counter was awesome and very insightful. Provided excellent service, was very organized and had fair pricing for the cards we purchased. There was also a customer in the store too that was…

CH
Conner Horncastle
3 weeks ago

I love this place. So many great people and a pretty laid back atmosphere. The employees, Frank and Nick (affectionately referred to as Nutmeg), really know their stuff and I genuinely feel valued as a customer when making a purchase or sale. I’ve met some of my best friends…

SM
Steve Moore
a month ago

Do not bring your cards here. They only offer 50%. They act like you owe them something. No hello when you walk in. Musty smelling and filthy inside. Just a bad experience as soon as the door opened.

CH
Chaz Hendrick
3 months ago

This is the coolest place around. I drove from Rochester just to go there. The man behind the counter that goes by Frankie deserves a massive raise. Charismatic and Knowledgeable even about games that the store does not have.