Magic
Sealed
11 miChart a course
Loading map…
The Game Cave
WPN
SinglesSealed
What you'll find in the bins
About
Batavia's spot for paper Magic, billed as the only place in town with MTG tournaments and singles. Expect a deep Standard, Modern and Legacy singles selection plus restockable sealed at or below MSRP. Yu-Gi-Oh and D&D round out the focus, with a welcoming play space for board games and RPGs too.
Good to know
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entranceAccessible parking
Payment
Credit cardsDebit cardsContactless / tap
From 39 customer reviews
What the players say
Great place to start learning how to play mtg, and fun events. everyone I have meet so far has been patient with me still learning the game. Frank has been a huge help with getting me the cards I needed or pointing me in the right direction for my decks.
RW
Richie Williams
a month ago
My son and I stopped by this shop while we were in town for a few days. The guy behind the counter was awesome and very insightful. Provided excellent service, was very organized and had fair pricing for the cards we purchased. There was also a customer in the store too that was…
CH
Conner Horncastle
3 weeks ago
I love this place. So many great people and a pretty laid back atmosphere. The employees, Frank and Nick (affectionately referred to as Nutmeg), really know their stuff and I genuinely feel valued as a customer when making a purchase or sale. I’ve met some of my best friends…
SM
Steve Moore
a month ago
Do not bring your cards here. They only offer 50%. They act like you owe them something. No hello when you walk in. Musty smelling and filthy inside. Just a bad experience as soon as the door opened.
CH
Chaz Hendrick
3 months ago
This is the coolest place around. I drove from Rochester just to go there. The man behind the counter that goes by Frankie deserves a massive raise. Charismatic and Knowledgeable even about games that the store does not have.