Magic
Singles
Loading map…
Paper or Plastic Sports and Games
WPN
Sealed
What you'll find in the bins
About
Shorewood's quirky mashup of disc golf and tabletop, Paper or Plastic carries Magic, Lorcana, and Star Wars Unlimited sealed alongside board games and discs. Daily in-store events and Saturday Commander keep the play space busy, and the cozy, well-laid-out shop is a friendly stop for players of every level.
Good to know
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entranceAccessible parkingAccessible restroomAccessible seating
Parking
Free parking lot
Payment
Credit cardsDebit cardsContactless / tap
From 293 customer reviews
What the players say
This is one of my all time favorite game shops! They have a great selection of card and board games. The owner and staff are awesome. Very friendly and helpful. There is rarely ever a time when we don’t find something to buy here. My son loves their Pokemon cards amd they always…
MA
Marc
6 months ago
Drove almost two hours to visit, and it was 100% worth it! Picked up two Dragonball Super Prismatic Clash booster boxes and a Demon Slayer pack for my niece. The price was a little more than expected, but the staff and owner were incredibly kind and immediately price-matched…
KK
Kray Kidboy
2 months ago
I’ve been going here for years without having to worry about new product being crazy over msrp. Honestly the shelves were always flying because even when market was 200% day after release they would restock at like 60% above market. These card shops blame tcg distribution for…
BZ
Billy Zeitz
3 months ago
Went there for the TMNT pre-release and had lots of fun with me and three other coworkers. Great atmosphere everyone was very friendly it is a rare card shop that's a diamond in the rough.
AA
Ana A
2 months ago
Don't go. Their tournaments are a robbery. Keeping all of the given prices by Bandai to themselves. Also there are specific employees there that shouldn't be working there. They really come out being rude when "we" the customers the reason they are in business.