Nutmeg Games

I used to be a frequent customer here, but unfortunately I won’t be returning after my experience this week. I stopped in on Friday planning to purchase a full collector box of Magic: The Gathering cards (a large buy). During checkout the employee realized she had quoted me the… Read more

I'll preface this by saying this. I moved to New Milford in July of 2023, and was incredibly happy to see a LGS! It's something that I dreamed of having nearby as a kid. After settling in I visited the shop with my daughter and spoke to some amazing staff, we grabbed a My Hero… Read more

First and last time at this store. I’m all for supporting local game stores, but their prices are absolutely ridiculous. For example, they charged $35 for entry to a Lorcana set championship, whereas Goblins right down the road charged $10. Additionally, all of their in store… Read more

I used to be a semi frequent buyer here and after my last experience I will never be returning, because the store has become a scam. I brought in a wan shi tung borderless holo card for instore credit or cash that comes in a $50 collector pack. The store tried to offer me $40… Read more

HOLY SCALPER! No worse than scalper. They are asking for close to triple msrp. 3 packs for $50 and no not vintage or stuff they stopped printing a $15 pack for $50. 2 pack mini tins for $30 like what. Some of the WORST prices I’ve ever seen. Don’t shop here go anywhere else go… Read more