Sports
Singles Sealed
Loading map…
Lost Trove Collectibles
SinglesSealed
Vintage
What you'll find in the bins
About
A New Berlin treasure box of nostalgia, packed with vintage Star Wars, GI Joe, Transformers and Marvel/DC figures alongside Pokemon cards and singles. Owner John is famously friendly and fair, often matching or beating online prices when buying and selling. A small but mighty stop for collectors chasing 90s and retro finds.
Good to know
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entranceAccessible parking
Payment
Credit cardsDebit cardsContactless / tap
From 32 customer reviews
What the players say
Awesome place! Excellent customer service. The owner is kind and friendly and has been so generous with my boys and their love of Pokémon cards. We always have a good time when we come here. Good assortment of products, although we typically are shopping for Pokémon product.
DO
Daniel Oleszek
10 months ago
First time visiting. I had a bunch of star wars figures to sell. Gave me a good price. Instead of cash I was able to buy 2 vintage star wars figures for my collection. The owner was very friendly and knowledgeable. I will definitely be coming back. I highly recommend Lost Trove…
JS
joseph strieter
5 months ago
Great service and a very friendly owner made this shop a pleasure to visit. It’s the perfect spot for GI Joe, Transformers, Star Wars, Marvel/DC, Godzilla, and just about any other “nerdy” collectibles you can think of. Prices are very fair (at or below ebay sales value),…
KA
Kiara A
5 months ago
An absolutely wonderful place to go for collectibles. The owner, John, has a little bit of everything for everyone and is incredibly knowledgeable about everything he has. A great passion for his store and what he does. Amazing prices for great quality stock. Will definitely be…
LS
Leo Synowicz
4 months ago
Best collector toy store in entire Milwaukee area. New stuff, old stuff, even not so old stuff. Large variety of collectable toys. Best prices in town for buying and selling collectibles. John the owner is the friendliest shop owner I've met in years. If you have a question…