MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaStar WarsFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
Loading map…
Indy Card Exchange
SinglesSealed
Graded cardsBuys collectionsSuppliesVintage
What you'll find in the bins
About
A full-service Indianapolis card shop running since the early 1990s, deep in sports singles, packs and wax boxes across baseball, basketball, football, hockey and soccer. Non-sport too, including Pokemon and Star Wars, plus on-site grading, autograph authentication and live breaks.
Good to know
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entranceAccessible parking
Payment
Credit cardsDebit cardsContactless / tap
From 372 customer reviews
What the players say
This place is AWESOME!!! Every single person on staff was super friendly, super helpful, and very respectful. The store itself was super cool. It's a throwback to childhood, and I was able to get some great Jordan cards and to see an AMAZING diy Jordan card table top where kids…
AM
Aaron McCain
3 months ago
The people that work here are rude and disrespectful. I was told by a few people to come here and that they could help me but when I tried that acted like I didn't matter and was more of an inconvenience to them. They just wanted me to leave so I did. The prices are way more…
JC
Jeffrey Cheng
a year ago
Indy Card Exchange is a gem for sports card enthusiasts! I recently visited and found some amazing NBA cards featuring my childhood heroes like Michael Jordan, Allen Iverson, Kobe Bryant, and Vince Carter. This store brought back so many good memories! What I love about Indy…
MS
Maddie Sawyer
3 months ago
Very cool place! Not my personal scene but for anyone that loves trading cards or exchanging them for fair prices, come here! They are super sweet and the atmosphere is so much fun!!!
MB
Making Spirits Bright
a year ago
Absolutely outstanding experience at Indy Card Exchange in Fishers, Indiana! I recently brought in 9 sports cards to be evaluated and cleaned before grading, and I can’t say enough good things about the service i received. Kevin did a phenomenal job carefully cleaning and…