IChooseYou is an Andover, New Jersey card shop that leads with Pokemon and a genuinely deep Flesh and Blood obsession, also stocking Magic, Lorcana and Star Wars Unlimited. Sealed product fills the shelves while singles run through their TCGplayer Pro storefront, backed by 25,000-plus sales and a busy in-store play community.

Good to know

Payment

Credit cardsDebit cards

What the players say

Kyle Fierravanti

a month ago

GREAT selection of Pokemon and Magic the Gathering cards! The owner and employees are FRIENDLY and passionate about their business. Prices are EXTREMELY REASONABLE and they make your experience EASY and enjoyable. Thank you for an AWESOME card niying experience! 10/10 A+++

Ian Rosenberg

4 months ago

A genuinely nice guy! I love to trade my duplicate hits and newer sealed stuff so I can fill in the gaps in my collection as a kid. Anyone that rates anything less than 5 stars here outs themselves a mad scalper. Goodness is returned in kind. Ive seen the genuine expression…

Cody Winters

8 months ago

mMy favorite card shops around hands down. The owner tries his hardest to keep new sets as cheap as possible despite the scalping on a level we have never seen. You know it's bad when a card store owner struggles to get an allotment of any type of TCG, at or, God forbid below…

little squishy /lSQ

4 months ago

A amazing person with great prices. I went in to sell slabs,cards and pokemon products and he was very friendly, helpful and gave amazing prices. The shop and community is amazing there i highly recommend going to check them out and chat with the friendly community. I will be…

ERV

3 months ago

What a nice little place! Went there today for the first time as I realized it’s just minutes away from my house. Went in and the worker was super helpful as I am new to Pokemon. What I do know is about reselling and was surprised they had the Perfect Order ETB available! They…

IChooseYou TCGs

What you'll find in the bins

About

Good to know

What the players say

Stores nearby