MagicPokémonBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
Magic Stores in Indiana
Across Indiana, 96 local game stores carry Magic, spread over 54 cities. 88 sell singles and 94 keep sealed product in stock. Jump to a city below, or scan every listing for hours and what each shop stocks.
- 96stores
- 4.6★avg rating
- 13,894reviews
Magic by city in Indiana: Indianapolis (18), Clarksville (4), Anderson (3), Bloomington (3), Carmel (3), Evansville (3), Jeffersonville (3), Avon (2), Brownsburg (2), Crown Point (2), Greenfield (2), Greenwood (2), Kokomo (2), New Albany (2), Noblesville (2), Plainfield (2), Scottsburg (2), South Bend (2), Valparaiso (2), Angola (1), Chesterton (1), Clinton (1), Columbus (1), Decatur (1), Elwood (1), Fishers (1), Fort Wayne (1), Fowler (1), Franklin (1), Fremont (1), Garrett (1), Goshen (1), Greencastle (1), Jasper (1), La Porte (1), Lafayette (1), Lebanon (1), Logansport (1), Lowell (1), Martinsville (1), Mishawaka (1), Mooresville (1), Munster (1), Plymouth (1), Portage (1), Portland (1), Richmond (1), Schererville (1), Sellersburg (1), Seymour (1), Terre Haute (1), Warsaw (1), West Lafayette (1), Whiteland (1)
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceStar WarsRiftboundBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcana
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicStar WarsBoard & Other
Sealed
4.8(231)Chart a course
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonOne PieceLorcanaSports
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!LorcanaStar WarsRiftboundFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémon
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!SportsBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaStar WarsRiftboundFlesh & Blood
Singles Sealed
4.9(57)Chart a course
MagicBoard & Other
Sealed
MagicBoard & Other
Singles
MagicOne PieceBoard & Other
Sealed
MagicPokémon
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!Board & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonLorcanaStar WarsRiftboundBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonLorcanaBoard & Other
Sealed
MagicPokémonLorcanaFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceRiftboundBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonOne Piece
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!LorcanaStar WarsFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonLorcanaBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaStar WarsFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaStar WarsBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaSports
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonOne PieceLorcana
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
4.8(8)Chart a course
MagicBoard & Other
MagicPokémonBoard & Other
Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!One PieceLorcanaFlesh & BloodBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
4.6(91)Chart a course
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!LorcanaStar WarsBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonOne PieceLorcanaRiftboundBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonOne PieceLorcanaBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonLorcanaBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonYu-Gi-Oh!LorcanaSports
Singles Sealed
MagicPokémonBoard & Other
Singles Sealed
Showing the top 48 of 96 stores. The city links above list every shop in each spot.
Finding Magic across Indiana
88 of the 96 Magic stores in Indiana deal in single cards. Hunting a specific staple? Start with those, and call ahead, since binder stock varies shop to shop. 94 keep sealed product on the shelf: booster boxes, bundles, packs. 87 handle both singles and sealed, which saves a second stop.
Shoppers rate these stores 4.6★ on average across 13,894 Google reviews. Each listing shows current hours and what the shop carries.
Frequently asked questions
- Which cities in Indiana have Magic stores?
- 54 Indiana cities have at least one store carrying Magic, with the most listings in Indianapolis, Clarksville, and Anderson. The city links above go straight to each local list.
- Where can I buy Magic singles in Indiana?
- 88 of the 96 Indiana stores carrying Magic deal in single cards. Each listing on this page shows whether a shop sells singles, sealed product, or both.
- Do Indiana game stores stock sealed Magic product?
- 94 stores in Indiana stock sealed product such as booster boxes and packs. Sealed availability turns over with each set release, so check a shop's listing for hours before making the drive.
- How are Magic stores in Indiana rated?
- Customers average 4.6 stars over 13,894 Google reviews across the Magic stores listed here.
Other games in Indiana: Board & Other, Flesh & Blood, Lorcana, One Piece, Pokémon, Riftbound, Sports, Star Wars, Yu-Gi-Oh!